The Ultimate Playbook for Marketing Distribution Channels - Part 2 of 3
Learn why marketing channels fail and how to fix them, create a winning marketing playbook, and develop a solid fallback strategy when channels underperform.
We have covered the following topics in Part 1 of “Ultimate Playbook of Marketing Distribution Channels” Series...
1. Marketing Channels
2. How to Pick the Right Marketing Channels
3. How to Test a Marketing Channel
4. B2B and B2C Marketing KPIs
We are going to cover the following below…
5. Why Marketing Channels Fail (and How to Fix Them)
6. Iteration Plan for Marketing Channels
7. Plan When a Marketing Channel Underperforms
8. Channel Selection & Testing Checklist
And...
We will cover the following topics in Part 3 (Would be released in coming weeks) - Subscribe to receive updates
9. Blueprint for an Optimized Marketing Channel Mix
10. Managing Multi-Channel Campaigns
11. How Marketing Channels Align with the GTM (Go-To-Market) Funnel – B2B vs. B2C
12. Common Pitfalls to Avoid in the Marketing Channel Process (and How to Fix Them)
13. The Growth Path: Scaling Marketing Channels After Testing Success
14. Tools to Identify Untapped Marketing Channels
15. Aligning Your Channel Mix with the Buyer’s Journey
16. Tools for Cross-Channel Attribution and Automation – B2B vs. B2C
Why Marketing Channels Fail (and How to Fix Them)
Marketing channels don’t always perform as planned.
Sometimes it’s like running uphill, no matter how much effort you put in.
Let’s break down the most common reasons channels don’t work — and the ways to revive them.
Reason 1: Misaligned Messaging
You might be targeting the right audience, but your message is not catching their attention.
- Problem: Messaging feels generic or doesn’t connect with what the audience needs. (because it's not tailored)
- Example: A SaaS product runs ads saying, “Boost productivity.” But the audience doesn’t care about productivity—they want less work and more results.
Messaging isn’t just about benefits—it’s about what your audience values right now.
Fix:
Interview customers to find out their language and priorities.
A/B test two versions: “Boost Productivity” vs. “Automate Boring Tasks.”
Double down on the message that performs best.
Calendly improved their marketing outcomes by shifting their messaging from individual productivity to team efficiency, which resonated better with enterprise clients. This change maximized conversions on B2B channels like LinkedIn.
Reason 2: Targeting the Wrong Audience
Your product may be great, but you’re showing it to the wrong people.
- Problem: Channels aren’t segmented properly.
- Example: A luxury watch brand targets everyone between 25-50 on Instagram. But most of their real buyers are high-earning executives over 40.
Niche down. Tighter targeting often performs better than broad campaigns.
Fix:
Use lookalike audiences based on existing buyers.
Segment ads by demographics, income, and interests.
Test niche audiences to identify where engagement spikes.
A D2C mattress brand wasted $50,000 targeting a broad audience. They switched to expecting parents and new homeowners, reducing CAC by 35%.
Reason 3: Budget Misallocation
Some channels just keep spending money—the more you allow them, the more they spend.
- Problem: Too much budget goes to underperforming channels.
- Example: A SaaS company spends 80% of their budget on Google Ads. But their best leads actually come from LinkedIn outreach.
Follow the data—not your gut.
Fix:
Use multi-channel tracking to see where conversions come from.
Reallocate budget based on real ROI—not assumptions.
Run incremental tests: Shift 10-15% of the budget to new channels and compare results.
A fitness app halved its Google Ad spend and invested in influencer partnerships. Within 3 months, their acquisition cost dropped by 40%, and subscriptions soared.
Reason 4: Lack of Channel-Specific Strategy
What works on one platform won’t automatically work on another. A killer Instagram campaign might flop on LinkedIn.
- Problem: Marketers repurpose the same strategy across multiple channels.
- Example: A B2B SaaS company posts the same meme on LinkedIn that they used on Instagram — no response on LinkedIn.
Each channel has its own culture and style. Adapt or fail.
Fix:
Develop channel-specific playbooks.
Understand what the audience expects on each platform.
Example: Use personal memes for Instagram and industry specific memes for LinkedIn.
A recruiting agency adapted its campaigns for Twitter by using short polls instead of boring posts—and tripled engagement.
Reason 5: Weak Follow-Up Systems (B2B)
You got the lead—but the follow-up was slow or weak. And now, the lead is cold.
- Problem: Leads slip through the cracks because marketing and sales aren’t aligned.
- Example: A lead requests a demo, but the sales team only follows up 5 days later. By then, the buyer has gone with another vendor.
Speed matters in B2B. Leads get cold fast.
Fix:
Set up an automated follow-up sequence to engage leads immediately.
Sync CRM systems so both teams stay on the same page.
Use tools like HubSpot to alert sales when a lead shows high intent (e.g., visits the pricing page).
Success Story: A SaaS company reduced response time from 3 days to 1 hour using automated email alerts—and closed 20% more deals in 6 months.
Reason 6: Ignoring Funnel Velocity (B2C)
In B2C, slow funnels kill conversions. If a customer takes too long to make a decision, they move on.
- Problem: There are too many steps in the purchase journey.
- Example: A clothing brand makes users create an account before buying. The friction causes them to abandon carts.
Counterpoint: The faster the purchase, the better. Reduce friction.
Fix:
Use one-click checkout options like Apple Pay.
Add retargeting ads to bring back abandoned shoppers.
Offer limited-time discounts to speed up decisions.
A D2C coffee brand removed the account-creation step and reduced cart abandonment by 25%.
Reason 7: Poor Creative Execution
Even the best strategy fails if the creative doesn’t catch attention. In a noisy world, boring ads doesn’t catch any attention.
- Problem: The creative lacks a strong hook or clear value.
- Example: A skincare brand uses generic images of lotion bottles instead of before-and-after results.
Great creatives grab attention in 2 seconds or less.
Fix:
Use bold visuals and emotional storytelling.
A/B test different creatives to see which one resonates.
Highlight customer testimonials or user-generated content.
A beauty brand swapped stock images for real customer photos. Their CTR doubled within 2 weeks.
Marketing channels fail when you assume they’ll just work without tuning. Test, adapt, and double down on what works.
Even big brands get it wrong, but the ones that thrive are obsessed with learning and tweaking. So, when a channel isn’t working—don’t shut it down immediately. Fix the creative, adjust targeting, or try a new message.
Iteration Plan for Channels - Distribution Playbook
You don’t need to scrap a channel just because it didn’t work the first time.
Good marketing isn’t a one-shot game—it’s a process of constant iteration.
Here’s a plan to fine-tune your channels, shift strategies, and optimize for better results without blowing your budget.
Step 1: Design Your Next Experiment - From your Marketing Playbook
Think of each test as a small bet. Run quick experiments with tight controls so you can isolate what works.
- Goal: Focus on one variable at a time—creative, audience, or offer.
- Example: A SaaS company runs two LinkedIn ads. One focuses on features, the other on return on investment benefits.
Tip: Write down a simple hypothesis.
Example: “If we shift to ROI messaging, we’ll increase click-through rates by 15%.”
Step 2: Identify Micro-Metrics to Monitor
Big metrics like conversion rates don’t convey complete stories. Look at micro-metrics for insights along the way.
Top-of-Funnel Micro-Metrics (Awareness)
- CTR (Click-Through Rate)
- Bounce Rate
- Scroll Depth
- Example: If CTR is high but bounce rate spikes, your ad works, but your landing page needs fixing.
Mid-Funnel Micro-Metrics (Engagement)
- Time on Page
- Webinar Sign-Ups
- Email Open Rates
- Example: If emails have high open rates but low clicks, your CTA might need reworking.
Bottom-of-Funnel Micro-Metrics (Conversion)
- Add-to-Cart Rate
- Demo Requests
- Retargeting Clicks
- Example: If retargeted users aren’t converting, your offer might not be compelling enough.
Opinion: Micro-metrics show you exactly where things are going off-track.
Step 3: Shift Strategies Mid-Test
If your experiment isn’t giving you results, don’t wait until it’s over to adjust. Make changes on the fly.
Tweak Creative
- Swap out headline hooks if CTR is low.
- Add urgency-based CTAs like “Limited Offer” to encourage action.
- Example: A fitness brand boosted conversions by 20% with a simple tweak from “Join Today” to “Act Fast – Spots Limited.”
Change Audience Targeting
- Narrow down to niche segments if your current targeting is too broad.
- Example: A B2B SaaS brand shifted focus from all HR professionals to just recruiting managers—and saw a 30% drop in CPL.
Adjust budget allocation mid-test. If one ad or segment is outperforming, put more budget there immediately.
Step 4: Retarget Smarter – Bring Back the Almost-Buyers
Retargeting is like giving people a second chance to say yes. But it’s only effective if it’s done right.
Audience Segments for Retargeting
- Users who clicked but didn’t convert.
- Visitors who abandoned carts.
- Webinar attendees who didn’t book a demo.
Ad Creative for Retargeting
- Offer time-sensitive discounts to activate explorers.
- Use social proof—like reviews or testimonials—to build trust.
- Example: A D2C fashion brand used retargeting ads with customer photos and doubled its ROAS in 2 weeks.
Retargeting isn’t about pushing—it’s about adding value and removing hesitation.
Step 5: Optimize Creative Assets Continuously
Creative fatigue is real. Ads get old fast, and audiences stop engaging. Keep your creatives fresh.
Rotation Strategy
- Change creatives every 2-3 weeks to avoid fatigue.
- Example: A tech brand rotates between videos, carousel ads, and static images to keep engagement high.
User-Generated Content (UGC)
- Use real customer photos or reviews in your ads.
- Example: Glossier relies heavily on UGC, making their ads feel authentic and relatable.
A/B Test Asset Formats
- Example: Test a carousel ad vs. a single image ad on Instagram to see which drives more clicks.
Your ad creative is like a movie trailer—you wouldn’t run the same one forever. Keep evolving.
Step 6: Document Learnings and Plan Next Iteration
Iteration isn’t just about tweaking—it’s about learning. Document what works (and what doesn’t) so you can improve faster next time.
What to Log:
- Which audience segments performed best?
- Which creatives drove the most engagement?
- What micro-metrics pointed to hidden issues?
Example of Iteration:
- After testing Pinterest Ads, a D2C home décor brand realized their best audience was new homeowners. They shifted all future campaigns to this segment and increased ROAS by 40%.
The goal isn’t to run one perfect campaign—it’s to keep experimenting. Each iteration brings you one step closer to better performance. Keep testing, tweaking, and paying attention to the small wins.
Good marketing is a series of small bets that add up to big wins.
When a Distribution Channel Underperforms - Create a Marketing Playbook
Sometimes, no matter how hard you try, a channel just won’t work.
Maybe it’s a bad fit, or the timing is off.
When that happens, don’t panic—pivot. Here’s how to rethink your strategy, repurpose resources, and learn from the failure without skipping a beat.
Step 1: Conduct a Root Cause Analysis
Before moving on, figure out what went wrong. You don’t want to repeat the same mistakes elsewhere.
Ask Critical Questions:
- Was it the wrong audience or channel fit?
- Did our messaging fail to attract?
- Was there enough budget to give it a fair shot?
What to Look For:
- CTR too low? Your ad didn’t resonate.
- Leads didn’t convert? Look for friction points in the funnel (bad landing page, unclear CTA).
- High CPC or CAC? The channel might not scale profitably.
Example: A SaaS company running Google Ads found they had too many clicks from the wrong keywords. They pivoted by focusing on exact match keywords—and cut their CPL in half.
Step 2: Explore Alternative Strategies – Pivot Smartly
If one channel isn’t working, it’s time to pivot. Here are a few options to keep the momentum going.
1. Multi-Channel Funnel Approach
Don’t put all your eggs in one basket. Layer multiple channels to catch leads at different stages.
- Example: Combine Google Ads (intent) with Facebook retargeting (awareness).
- How It Works: Someone clicks your Google Ad but doesn’t convert. Your retargeting ad brings them back later.
Opinion: Multi-channel strategies spread risk. If one channel slows down, another can pick up.
2. Reallocate Budget to Higher-Performing Channels
If one channel underdelivers, double down on what’s already working.
- Example: A DTC brand found Instagram Ads were outperforming TikTok. They moved 30% of their ad spend to Instagram and saw a 20% boost in sales.
Tip: Always leave room in your budget for experiments—but don’t be afraid to pull the plug if something isn’t working.
3. Shift to Organic and Referral Strategies
If paid channels aren’t delivering, lean into organic channels or referrals.
- Referral Tactic: Create an incentive, like “Give $20, Get $20”.
- Organic Play: Build content that answers questions your audience is already asking (SEO).
Example: Dropbox used referrals to grow 4 million users in 15 months without heavy ad spend.
4. Partner with Influencers or Industry Experts
Sometimes, borrow trust from those your audience already listens to.
- Example: A fitness app collaborated with micro-influencers to drive installs after Facebook Ads failed.
- Result: They doubled their user base within 6 weeks—without spending extra on ads.
Step 3: Adjust the Funnel – Optimize for Conversion
If a channel isn’t working, the problem might not be the channel itself—but the funnel.
Review Your Funnel Stages:
- Where are people dropping off?
- Does the landing page align with the ad message?
- Is your offer clear and compelling?
Example: A SaaS company improved its demo conversion rate by removing unnecessary form fields—and increased sign-ups by 25%.
Tip: Make sure your entire funnel flows smoothly, from the first click to checkout.
Step 4: Repurpose Content Across Channels
If a channel fails, it doesn’t mean the content isn’t working. Repurpose it for other channels.
Example: If your Facebook ad creative didn’t convert, try turning it into:
- A LinkedIn post targeting professionals.
- An email campaign for retargeting your leads.
- A blog post to build SEO traffic.
Good content can flow into many different channels.
Step 5: Test New Channels on a Small Scale
Sometimes, the solution lies in finding new territory.
Example: If Instagram Ads didn’t work, try Pinterest or YouTube Shorts.
- How to Test:
- Allocate 5-10% of your budget to new channels.
- Run small experiments—look for quick wins before scaling up.
Tip: Don’t be afraid to explore niche platforms where your competitors aren’t playing yet.
When a channel doesn’t perform -- stay curious, pivot quickly, and keep experimenting. What works today might not work tomorrow, and that’s okay. Just keep testing, tweaking, and moving forward.
Channel Selection & Testing Checklist
Choosing and testing the right channel is like finding the perfect playbook.
This checklist will help you pick the right channel, run smart tests, and hit your goals faster.
1. Confirm Product-Market Fit First
If your product doesn’t resonate with your audience, no channel will save you.
- Ask Yourself:
- Do I have paying customers?
- Have I identified real demand for the product?
- Are customers giving positive feedback or referring others?
Example: Before diving into ads, Airbnb focused on perfecting the user experience for hosts and travelers. Ads came later—and worked because the product already fit the market.
2. Align the Channel with Your GTM Strategy
The channel you choose should match your growth goals and funnel strategy.
- B2B Example: Use LinkedIn Ads if you’re targeting executives or enterprise buyers.
- B2C Example: Go with Instagram Ads if you’re selling beauty products or lifestyle services.
Tip: Don’t force-fit a channel. Align it with how your audience prefers to buy.
3. Build Audience Personas and Map Them to Channels
If you’re selling to everyone, you’re selling to no one. Know your ideal buyer inside and out.
What to Include in a Persona:
- Demographics (age, location, income).
- Psychographics (interests, values, habits).
- Preferred Platforms (LinkedIn, Instagram, YouTube).
Example: A productivity app realized their ideal user wasn’t just “busy professionals” but mid-level managers juggling family and career. They shifted to Facebook Ads—and conversions shot up.
4. Plan the Budget (Don’t Guess)
Budget mismanagement is like leaving the money on the table.
Set Budget Expectations:
- Start small: 5-10% of your monthly marketing budget.
- Plan for 3 rounds of testing—don’t make decisions off one test.
- Keep 20-30% reserved for unexpected channel shifts.
If you burn your entire budget upfront, you won’t have the flexibility to adapt.
5. Define KPIs Before Launching
A channel without KPIs is like moving blindfold.
- Examples of Channel KPIs:
- CPL (Cost per Lead) – Measures efficiency of lead generation.
- ROAS (Return on Ad Spend) – Evaluates campaign profitability.
- Engagement Rate – Gauges audience interest (likes, comments, shares).
- Conversion Rate – Measures how well traffic converts into customers.
Tip: Choose 1-2 core KPIs per channel to avoid data overload.
6. Set the Test Duration – Long Enough to Learn
Give enough time to your tests for it to give validated results.
Recommended Test Duration:
- Paid campaigns: 2-4 weeks minimum.
- Organic strategies: At least 90 days.
- Tip: Monitor weekly, but let the full test run to get meaningful data.
Example: A SaaS brand almost killed their Google Ads campaign after week one. By week three, CTR improved by 40% after minor tweaks.
7. Set a Communication Cadence with Stakeholders
Keep stakeholders in the loop, or you’ll end up explaining surprises later.
- Best Practices:
- Send weekly updates with KPIs and test progress.
- Schedule a mid-test sync to discuss early learnings.
- Deliver a post-campaign report highlighting wins, losses, and next steps.
Transparency with stakeholders builds trust—and helps secure more budget if you need it.
8. Test Small Before Going Big - Create a Marketing Playbook for Team
Always start small and iterate fast.
How to Start:
- Run a pilot campaign with limited spend.
- A/B test creatives, audiences, or CTAs.
- Example: Test two different headlines—one focused on price, the other on value.
Tip: Treat every test as a mini-experiment. Document what works and what flops.
9. Monitor Results in Real-Time (Stay Agile and Focus on Successful Marketing Campaigns)
Waiting until the end of the campaign to review results is too late. Stay on top of performance.
Use Tools:
- Google Analytics for web traffic.
- Facebook Ads Manager for campaign metrics.
- HubSpot or Salesforce for lead tracking.
What to Watch:
- CTR dropping? Time to refresh your creative.
- CPL too high? Revisit your targeting.
- Leads but no conversions? Audit your funnel for leaks.
10. Plan for Pivot Points – Be Ready to Adjust
Even the best plans hit roadblocks. Stay flexible and be ready to pivot.
When to Pivot:
- If CTR is low after multiple creative changes.
- If conversions stall despite high traffic.
- If CAC is higher than LTV.
Example: A food delivery startup ran Google Ads but struggled with acquisition costs. They pivoted to TikTok influencer partnerships—and saw 3x the ROI.
Choosing and testing a channel isn’t a one-and-done task. It’s a cycle of learning, iterating, and optimizing. With the right checklist, you’ll know exactly where to steer and when to pivot.
Loved this post?
If you’re not a subscriber, here’s what you missed earlier:
ConvertKit (Now Kit) Growth Story - How Nathan Barry bootstrapped to $36.4M Recurring Revenue
SaaS Conversion Strategies - Activation, Engagement, and Monetization - Part 2
Subscribe to get access to the latest marketing, strategy and go-to-market techniques . Follow me on Linkedin and Twitter.
